Archive for the ‘Cop Watch’ Category

May 25th, 2011

Wrongful Death Lawsuit Filed in Federal Court Against 3 Texas Cops By Family of Jamaal Valentine

Federal District Judge Kenneth Hoyt of the United States District Court of the Southern District of Texas, Galveston Division, is presiding over a new lawsuit, just filed in the Galveston federal court as Case No. 3:11-cv-00229, by the loved ones of Jamaal Valentine (Angela Butler, Joslynn Terrell, and Crystal Truitt) for justice in the death of Mr. Valentine after he was beaten by three La Marque, Texas, police officers.

These three plaintiffs are arguing that while Jamaal Valentine was suffering from a heart attack, he tried to get medical help — only to face these three cops who not only beat him, but used a Tazer (stun gun made by Taser International Inc.) on the man.

Witnesses will testify that Mr. Valentine never tried to resist these police officers. Evidence will show that he died from their injuries.

The federal court of Judge Kenneth Hoyt, not a Texas courtroom, will be the place where the three plaintiffs will face off against not only these three police officers – Richard Garcia, Forest Gandy and Mike Keleman – but the former chief of police for La Marque, Richard Price, and the City of La Marque itself.  There are five (5) defendants in the case.

A Nightmare of Police Gone Wrong

Within court documents, media reports reveal that Mr. Valentine was home when he began to have chest pains on May 16, 2009.  He was there, alone, and feeling bad.

Mr. Valentine went outside.  Things got worse, and he began to fear he was having a heart attack. So, Mr. Valentine flagged down the car driving by – and they stopped to help him.

It was a man named Keith Pope who was the Good Samaritan that evening.

Mr. Pope called 911.

Mr. Pope sat there with Mr. Valentine while they waited for EMS to show up.

Here’s where it gets very bizarre. According to the plaintiffs’ documents the 3 cops showed up (Garcia, Gandy and Keleman), pulled their guns, and told Valentine to put his hands behind his back. The suit alleges that they then beat this man with their fists and a flashlight, and they also used the stun gun on him. During this assault, Mr. Valentine was pleading with them.

Imagine the terror Jamaal Valentine must have felt.

About 30 minutes after the 911 call, EMS arrived. For some reason, according to the pleading, 20 more minutes passed before they actually helped Mr. Valentine.

It’s been over an hour now that Mr. Valentine has been having chest pain, having trouble.

At some point, EMS techs did load the injured man into their emergency vehicle and hit the road for Houston; however, the pleadings allege that for some reason the vehicle was re-routed to Texas City’s Mainland Medical Center in Texas City. At MMC, Mr. Valentine went into full cardiac arrest and died shortly after he got there.

Jamaal Valentine’s loved ones are asking for wrongful death, exemplary and survival damages in addition to attorney’s fees as allowed to them under Texas law.

April 20th, 2011

Veteran Dallas Cop To Be Fired After Discovery That He Lied In His Police Reports

Another veteran Texas cop is discovered to be bad news — seems like this is getting to be a regular news story, right?

This week, it was the Dallas Police Department who had the shameful task of informing the media and the public at large that a police force veteran (13 years) would face termination after the revelation of his bad acts.

Dallas Police Department Assistant Chief Vince Golbeck issued the formal recommendation to fire Senior Cpl. Avery Redd at a disciplinary hearing held last Thursday.

What Did the Bad Cop Do? He Lied.

At the disciplinary hearing, according to the Dallas Morning News, the assistant chief reported that Officer Redd had falsified two police reports.

The department’s internal affairs investigation apparently plowed through the work done by Officer Redd over the past few months, and discovered that things didn’t jive. Seems Redd:

1.  Claimed a Fantasy Arrest.  Redd filed a police report back in February 2011 that he had arrested a woman for criminal trespass — but it never happened.

2.  Took Toy Gun From Trucker and Filed It in Property Room as a Real Weapon.  In the same month, Officer Redd filed another report claiming to have checked a weapon into the DPD property room after he confiscated it from a big rig.  

It appears that something did make it into the property room — but not at the time that the police report filed by Redd claimed it was there.   Moreover, it wasn’t a real gun – even though Redd listed it as if it were a pistol in the report. 

Turns out that the dangerous weapon that he took from the big rig was a toy gun.  Toy. Gun.  Which he listed with a serial number on the report just like it was a Magnum 357 of Dirty Harry fame.  (Why?  Dunno.)

How did the dominoes start falling for Officer Redd?

Apparently, another cop turned him into the Powers That Be.  Seems one of his brother cops got ticked when Officer Redd asked him to cover for him by signing Redd out 20 minutes early for a moonlighting gig at a truck stop. 

This cop went to his supervisor and spilled the beans on Officer Redd.  The result today is that a cop who has been patroling the Dallas streets since 1998 is losing his job. 

Questions Pop Up for All of Us

Gotta wonder what would have happened if the other cop hadn’t gotten mad, right? 

And, of course, who is checking the veracity of police reports?  The system depends upon the honor and integrity of these reports.  Apparently, that is naive of us. 

Lesson learned:  a police report is only as reliable as the cop who wrote it up.

April 13th, 2011

Laredo Cop Moonlighting In the Cocaine Business Sentenced This Week to 25 Years in Fed Pen

There’s more and more media coverage about the Texas-Mexico border, and lots of debate over how dangerous it is - or isn’t - to travel through South Texas and down into Mexico.

Just this week, the Wall Street Journal reported on a warning issued by the U.S. Consultate’s Office in Monterrey that U.S. law enforcement officers or employees might be the targets of “Mexican criminal gangs” anywhere in the Mexican states of Tamaulipas, Nuevo León and San Luis Potosí.

Convicted Laredo Cop knows all about border drug traffic

However, there’s one thing for sure: Orlando Jesus Hale, 28, knows all about the drug smuggling business down near the border. Not that he’ll be profiting from it anytime soon: the former South Texas police officer was sentenced on Monday to 25 years in a federal prison. Seems Hale was caught and convicted of smuggling cocaine through Laredo.

This was no surprise to Officer Hale. He’d declined plea offers and faced a jury last September – and they had returned a guilty verdict on charges of (1) conspiracy to possess with intent to distribute cocaine and (2) using a firearm to further drug trafficking.

Back in 2008, Orlando Hale was playing both sides of the law: working as a law enforcement officer, and moonlighting as a navigator of sorts, helping cocaine shipments travel through local Texas traffic on their way from Mexico to their American destinations.

At his trial last fall, Hale’s partner-in-crime and former fellow cop Pedro Martinez III testified against him. (Martinez took a plea bargain, pleading guilty and avoiding a trial.)

These Laredo Cops Apparently Felt Safe Enough As They Negotiated Shipment Protection Fees

On the stand before the federal jury, Martinez told all about how the two police officers sat down with a man who they later learned was an undercover agent with the Federal Bureau of Investigation. There, in a Laredo hotel room, they described how they could protect cocaine shipments as they moved through Laredo, Texas. As part of the FBI sting, a deal was made for their Police Protection Service – and for $1000 apiece, the two cops protected a phony drug shipment. When the two cops showed up in San Antonio for their pay day, they were busted.

March 23rd, 2011

Texas Border Danger: New Website Invites Your Video, EMails Documenting Lack of Law Enforcement in South Texas

The Department of Agriculture has put up a website, ProtectYourTexasBorder, where anyone is invited to upload photographs, videos, or email their own personal stories about how dangerous it really is down there near the border between Texas and Mexico.

And by near the border, we mean anytime you get around 90 miles (or an hour and a half travel time) away on a major highway.

  • Your personal stories have to be 500 words or less.
  • You can stay anonymous if you’d like to do so.
  • Photos or videos max out at 10 MB – and it’s fine if they are also showing over at Flikr or YouTube.  No worries there.

Why is the State of Texas, of all things, putting up a website like this?

Well, seems like there are lots of people, including the head of the federal government’s Homeland Security, who are poo-pooing the idea that there’s a lot of violent activity here in South Texas and this site has been set up as a virtual soapbox so Texans (and presumably others, like Mexican Nationals, etc.) can share what they know. Or have seen or experienced.

There’s simply not enough manpower in the law enforcement in these areas to combat the influx of human trafficking, drugs, guns, etc. that is coming out of Mexico – and they’ll be the first to admit it. The State is providing this site as some support that the lack of police power or presence in this area is real.

Some Scary Stuff Down in South Texas is Being Documented Here

Already, stories are being shared at the site.  Scary stories.  Like the story where a South Texas rancher is abandoning his 38,000 acre ranch on Farm Road 755  and moving them to McAllen because it’s not safe to stay.  The ranch is 60 miles north of the border, and Farm Road 755 is great to drive if you’re wanting to avoid the checkpoints.  Watch the video, and learn how limited law enforcement is along this roadway.  Hear how the ranching family left their home only after having bullets zinging around their property at night and other dangers. 

Another one:  a Texas Ranger blunting telling a reporter that “we’re in a war” down in South Texas as the newscast delves into dangers this situation is causing to the national food supply as the cartels move further and faster into Texas farms and ranchlands.

The site is new.  There should be more stories over the next few months, so check back periodically to get more stuff. 

After so many posts discussing inept cops or corrupt police, this one is very different.  Here, there are huge amounts of territory where law enforcement simply doesn’t exist – or they are so outnumbered and outgunned that they won’t get out of the car (listen to the South Texas rancher video above to hear an officer say this exactly regarding stopping trucks on 755). 

There apparently just isn’t law enforcement, period, down there.

March 9th, 2011

More Cops Arrested for Breaking the Law: Two in Dallas, More in El Paso

In Dallas, two police officers have been arrested within the past week for doing bad things.  Neither one was on duty at the time. 

Dallas Police Officer Ralph McAfee was arrested on Sunday evening at his home after he and his girlfriend had a fight that apparently escalated into something that resulted in Officer McAfee being accused of assault/family violence.   McAfee is a 12 year veteran of the Dallas Police Department, and he is currently on administrative leave till these charges are resolved.

The same day that McAfee was arrested, another Dallas Police Officer was also arrested: Dallas cop Brandon Innes was arrested very early last Sunday morning (around 3 am) after he wrecked his car (no other vehicles were involved in the crash) and got busted for public intoxication.  (Seems Innes avoided a DUI charge because no one saw him behind the wheel, so there was no evidence, technically, that he was driving drunk. )  Innes is also currently on administrative leave.

So, within one 24 hour period, two members of Dallas law enforcement were arrested for assault and public intoxication (a narrow escape from a drunk driving charge).  However, that’s nothing when you compare what’s been going on over in El Paso recently.

As reported by Daniel Borunda of the El Paso Sun Times last week, El Paso Police Officer Zake Rivera has been arrested on suspicion of sexual assault after a family fight went bad and he and a fellow cop responded to the family disturbance call about the family fight going down.  Following standard operating procedure, the two policemen separated the couple who were fighting in order to question them, and according to the woman Officer Rivera placed her into the patrol car where the sexual assault is said to have occured.  Rivera was first placed on desk duty; he was later arrested by the Special Investigations Group (DNA testing was done), and a termination hearing was set to happen this week (March 7).

But this isn’t the only recent arrest of El Paso law enforcement.  As Mr. Borunda reports, there have been many allegations of bad things happening over there in the El Paso Police Department, including one police officer who was involved with an underage teenage girl (he was fired); another cop who was busted for allegedly stealing gifts while working off duty at a wedding reception; and another El Paso cop who was arrested for molesting a woman while she was unconscious. For details, check out Mr. Borunda’s story.

February 23rd, 2011

Great Texas Warrant Round-Up 2011 Starts on March 5 – Take Care of Your Outstanding Warrant Now

Once again it’s time for Texas law enforcement to try and clean their desks of outstanding arrest warrants by holding the state-wide Great Texas Warrant Roundup.  This will be the 5th year that Texas has done this, and this year over 240 jurisdictions (counties, municipalities, etc.) are involved. 

What is the Great Texas Warrant Roundup? 

This being Texas, it’s known as the largest such coordinated effort of its kind in the country, where folk who have outstanding warrants – for anything from traffic violations or unpaid parking tickets to those with higher charges – are invited to voluntarily comply with the local badges.  The incentive to do so?   Those who don’t may face being arrested (handcuffed, the whole bit) at their job or at home in front of their family - that’s the “roundup” part of this whole thing.

The List of All Participating Jurisdictions – Including Contact Information – Provided by KXII

KXII-TV.com has posted a list online that provides the names of all the participating jurisdictions, as well as contact information if you want to call and check on things.  Things like the number of outstanding warrants on file under your name, the logistics of taking care of any warrants before you are arrested, how much it’s gonna cost, etc.  Take care of the outstanding warrant before March 5th, and you won’t be busted.    

City of Arlington – Just One Example.

The City of Arlington has issued a new release, just like hundreds of others have been released across the state.  (Read it here.)  From the City of Arlington, according to the release:

In Arlington, notices have been mailed to individuals with active warrants. Inside the Star-Telegram beginning Sunday, Feb. 20, the City of Arlington will begin publishing the names of individuals with outstanding warrants. Names are also posted on the city’s website at www.arlingtontx.gov/municipalcourt.

During the next two weeks, Arlington residents with outstanding city citations are encouraged to appear in person or contact Arlington Municipal Court in order to avoid the embarrassment of being arrested at home, work or school during the Warrant Roundup.

How to clear an outstanding warrant:

  • Pay by phone at 1-888-604-7888 or online at www.arlingtontx.gov/municipalcourt
  • Appear at Arlington Municipal Court, located in the City Tower at 101 S. Mesquite St. Hours of opertion are 7 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. Monday through Friday.

Houston has issued a similar news release, with lots of details on how to take care of things.  Corpus Christi has its own, cursory news release giving instructions on what to do before March 5th.  Each jurisdiction has its own set of instructions on what to do, where to go – but they’re all agreed on the March 5th starting date, where officers will be specially assigned for one week to go out and arrest people with unresolved warrants. 

If you aren’t sure about whether you have an outstanding warrant, or what to do before March 5th, then check out the KXII list (above) or call your lawyer. 

February 16th, 2011

Police Brutality Videos Released: Texas Police Beatings and the Public Outcry in Houston

Beatings by police officers are not new; the new twist to this old story is how modern technology is giving us all a bird’s eye view of what cops can, and will, do to victims unable to defend themselves against assaults that often cause serious injuries and even death.  We’ve posted information and videos about these infuriating acts before — like this one, where cops in Paris, Texas are caught on camera beating Cornelius Gill and his friend

We’ve also posted information about how cop cams are becoming more and more popular; in Texas, they’re even being considered as part of the officer’s head gear - capturing what he does every step and every minute that he’s on duty.   We’re gonna see more and more video.  Police departments and prosecutors like cameras because they capture evidence the State can use against the accused.  Sometimes, however, these cameras proved to be invaluable to protect citizens against those in authority. 

When the videos point the finger back at the police, it comes as no surprise that horrific acts caught on tape might result in a bit of foot-dragging in releasing the videos to the public.    Which may well be what happened over in Houston, where two videos of police brutality that happened long ago just got released to the public

The first video shows cops beating a teenager, Chad Holley, back in March 2010.  Chad was 15 years old at the time, and suspected of burglary.  The second video captures a police officer beating Henry Madge, 27, in a hospital waiting room (of all places).  Both victims are African-American.

People in Houston got mad.  Understandably.  Lots of people. 

 So, a Town Hall Meeting was called over in Houston, and an amazing number of stories were shared by folk who came forward to tell about their own experiences with bad cops.  The NAACP was there, too — and they ended up distributing complaint forms to the crowd, to get details from everyone.  The NAACP will have a press conference tomorrow to release the details of what they’ve found.

The first video (of Chad Holley) was released by community activist Quanell XQuanell X is promsing to release more police brutality videos, too.

Here, the video of Chad Holley being beaten by the police, as he lies on the ground:

February 9th, 2011

Texas Police Are Tracking Your Every Move – Right Now – Through Automatic License Plate Readers Databases: Anyone Bother to Get Your Okay?

Automatic License Plate Readers, also known as License Plate Recognition Devices, have creeped into the daily routines of police departments across the State of Texas and elsewhere under the guise of cutting edge law enforcment technology used to capture criminals.  What the American public and the Texas citizenry are not being told is that it’s not just criminals, or accused criminals, that are getting recorded and reported: it’s all of us.

These Automatic License Plate Readers are placed in patrol cars, cameras on the hoods and boxes inside near the driver, where they automatically gather video data of every license plate that passes within their perimeter.  Every car.  Now, that doesn’t sound so bad until you learn that it’s not just one cop car at a single intersection doing this.  Nope. 

There are lots and lots and lots of gizmos out there, gathering into on license plates and where they are during the day or night.  This information is collected, and stored, giving the police the ability, should they choose to do so, of tracking any individual’s daily routine.  All by their car license tag.  Without their knowledge.  Without the person being accused of violating any law whatsoever.

These things are so commonplace that they have their own Wikipedia page, where “Automatic Number Plate Recognition,” is described as:

 … a mass surveillance method that uses optical character recognition on images to read the license plates on vehicles. They can use existing closed-circuit television or road-rule enforcement cameras, or ones specifically designed for the task. They are used by various police forces and as a method of electronic toll collection on pay-per-use roads and cataloging the movements of traffic or individuals.  ANPR can be used to store the images captured by the cameras as well as the text from the license plate, with some configurable to store a photograph of the driver. Systems commonly use infrared lighting to allow the camera to take the picture at any time of the day. ANPR technology tends to be region-specific, owing to plate variation from place to place.  Concerns about these systems have centered on privacy fears of government tracking citizens’ movements, misidentification and high error rates.

That’s right:  Texas law enforcement is using “mass surveillance” without your approval. 

The Highland Village Police Department is using this gizmo, and its Police Captain Corry Blount was recently quoted telling a San Antonio reporter  they don’t have a problem with having a database exceeding 700,000 hits (and growing) which they use as a reference tool in their investigations.  No, the individuals within the database are not notified that their information is contained within the Highland Village records. 

One of the suppliers of these Automatic License Plate Readers proudly touts the police departments of Tyler, Mesquite, and Houston as recent (and repeat) customers of its Platescan product, as well as Border Patrol organizations. 

Platescan also plans on expanding its service to sending advertisements to cars as they pass by commercial establishments — how clever, right?  This isn’t an invasion of privacy, it’s for our convenience.  Like we can’t see the Pizza Hut as we drive down the street, we need to get some advertisement inside our car that lets us know this? 

Sounds fishy, doesn’t it?  The ACLU thinks so.  The Texas Observer covered this threat to civil liberties last summer, in a cover story written by Forrest Wilder, “The Eyes of Texas Cops Are Upon You.”   One point made in the article: what happens when the police departments decide to share all this data, creating one big database?  (They’re already talking about it, all under the banner of crime investigation.)

You need to read this article, and you need to think about how much you value your right to privacy and your freedom here.  Because use of this Automatic License Plate Readers is clearly an invasion into your privacy and a threat to your civil liberties.   That’s not opinion: that’s fact.

January 26th, 2011

Texas Cops To Get Cameras on Their Heads: Now Will We See Even More Bad Acts than Dashcams Have Revealed?

Within the next 60 days, Austin police officers on foot and bike patrols will be participating in a national study on the effectiveness of having law enforcement wear little video cameras on their heads. That’s right: they will have little tiny web cabs on their caps or hats — or attached to their ears, like a Bluetooth.

Which means that now, law enforcement that is out there, dealing with the public, but without a dashcam camera since they don’t have a dashboard, will have their actions recorded on video for all of us to see. Get ready, YouTube.

Of course, the national testing of this new technology is all about the prosecution getting more evidence to use in criminal cases. For chain of custody purposes, the camera-wearing police officer cannot be able to tamper or edit the video feed – that’s important for the District Attorney in any criminal trial in order to authenticate and admit the video in the first place. The recordings will be automatically downloaded to a computer after the police officer finishes his shift, and presumably anything caught on the videos will be organized chronologically.

This gizmo isn’t new.  They’ve had versions of head-cams for years now, and in Great Britain, they even put these things on their police dogs.  The popularity of the camera-covered cop seems to be increasing:  Cincinnati likes them, various California law enforcement branches use them, and they’ve been around in Europe for years. 

Still, one has to wonder how much these cameras are going to be used to reveal cops gone bad – as the dashboard cameras on patrol cars have done so well.  Shedding light on police brutality is a good thing – and that’s a good result from this new technology.

However, taking it one step further – how long will it be before the shoe is put on the other foot, and the government seeks to put webcams into the lives of parolees or probationers?  Will the privacy arguments that failed with the ankle arrest bracelet prevail here?  Is anyone concerned about this?

January 12th, 2011

Plano Case Spotlights the Danger of Flashlights Strapped to Cop Guns: People Get Shot

The Dallas Morning News is helping spread the word this week about the dangers of a new gizmo that police departments around the country are using: the flashlight strapped onto a police pistol, its lens directly beneath the barrel of the gun.  More and more police departments are using these things.

 Problem is, like the Plano Police Department is all too aware, is that it’s all too easy for a cop in the street to trip the trigger instead of the light switch.  (Check out a photo of one these StarWarsesque light-pistols here.) Innocent people can get shot if the policeman makes a mistake and shoots a bullet instead of a light beam.  And they are. 

The family of Michael Anthony Alcala, 25, has filed a wrongful death lawsuit in Collin County against the Plano Police Department of the City of Plano, claiming that there are several negligent acts for which Plano is responsible that led to the death of their husband, son, and dad.  What happened? 

Last October, Mr. Alcala was shot down in a fast food restaurant parking lot (a Jack in the Box on North Dallas Tollway), dying sometime later at the hospital, after a Plano cop drew his Springfield .40-caliber semi-automatic pistol and shot by mistake as he was trying to turn on the gun’s attached SureFire X300 flashlight. (This, according to affidavits on file with the Dallas Police Department as reported by the Plano Star-Courier.)

These gun mount flashlights aren’t expensive: you take your pick from several products online.  In fact, these gizmos are promoted to police departments as being helpful: Streamlight markets its gun mounted flashlight to law enforcement customers as being lighter in “tactical situations” and “easier to handle and more importantly, provide significantly clearer identification of the target.”

Here’s the question:  how easy is it for a cop to make this kind of tragic mistake like the Plano death of Mr. Alcala?  And, to be fair, is this really a police negligence situation — or do we have a defective product here?  Gotta wonder.

One thing’s for sure:  be very nice and move really slowly after dark in Plano, Texas, if the cops stop you.